Rubrics communicate expectations by describing the criteria used to evaluate student work. In online courses, they help students understand what successful work looks like before beginning an assignment and provide a consistent framework for grading and feedback.
Rubrics benefit both students and instructors by:
- Clarifying expectations: Show students what is required and how their work will be evaluated.
- Supporting consistent grading: Apply the same criteria across student submissions.
- Making feedback more meaningful: Identify specific strengths and areas for improvement.
- Encouraging self-assessment: Help students review their work before submitting.
- Saving grading time: Reduce the need to write repetitive comments by using defined performance levels.
Rubrics are not ideal for all types of assessments, such as creative work. This can box students in and limit their creativity.
Tip
Add your rubric to Canvas so students can see it and use the criteria to guide their work.
Select a type below to learn more.
Analytic rubrics evaluate several criteria separately, with descriptions of different performance levels. They are useful for assignments requiring detailed grading and feedback.
Example
Case Study Analysis (12 points)
Criteria | Meets Expectations (4 pts) | Developing (2 pts) | Needs Improvement (0 pts) |
Analysis | Clearly identifies and analyzes key issues using course concepts. | Identifies key issues but provides limited analysis. | Does not clearly identify or analyze key issues. |
Evidence | Uses relevant evidence to support conclusions. | Includes some evidence, but connections are unclear. | Provides little or no relevant evidence. |
Recommendations | Provides a feasible recommendation supported by the analysis. | Provides a recommendation with limited justification. | Does not provide a clear or supported recommendation. |
Tip
Analytic rubrics are a good starting point for faculty new to online teaching because they make grading expectations explicit and help students identify specific areas for improvement.
Learn more: Rubrics: How to create an Analytic Rubric in Canvas
Holistic rubrics evaluate the overall quality of student work using a single rating rather than scoring individual criteria. They work well for shorter assignments, creative work, or assessments where an overall judgment is sufficient.
Example
Case Study Analysis
Rating | Description |
Excellent (4 pts) | Thoroughly analyzes the case, uses relevant evidence, and provides a well-supported recommendation. |
Proficient (3 pts) | Identifies and analyzes key issues, uses supporting evidence, and provides a reasonable recommendation. |
Developing (2 pts) | Demonstrates partial understanding, with limited analysis, evidence, or justification. |
Needs Improvement (0 pts) | Demonstrates minimal understanding and lacks a clear, supported recommendation. |
Tip
Although Canvas uses criterion-based rubrics, you can approximate a holistic rubric by creating one criterion that evaluates the assignment as a whole.
Learn More: Rubrics: How to create a Holistic Rubric in Canvas
Single-point rubrics describe what successful work looks like for each criterion without defining multiple performance levels. Instructors identify strengths and areas for improvement through written feedback. They are particularly useful for drafts, reflections, and assignments where individualized feedback is more important than assigning points.
Example
Case Study Analysis
Areas for Improvement | Meets Expectations | Strengths |
Needs to explain why the issues matter. | Analysis: Identifies and analyzes key issues using course concepts. | Clearly identifies the main problem. |
Connections between sources and conclusions need clarification. | Evidence: Uses relevant evidence to support conclusions. | Selects relevant supporting sources. |
Recommendation needs stronger justification. | Recommendations: Proposes a feasible solution supported by the analysis. | Suggests a practical solution. |
Tip
Canvas does not reproduce the traditional three-column single-point rubric exactly. The Written Feedback option is a practical alternative for providing criterion-specific comments without multiple performance ratings. If a grade is required, enter it separately in SpeedGrader when using an unscored rubric.
Learn More: Rubrics: How to create a Single-Point Rubric in Canvas
Choose an existing assignment and consider:
- Are the grading criteria aligned with the assignment's learning objectives?
- Do the performance descriptions clearly distinguish different levels of achievement?
- Can students use the rubric to evaluate their work before submitting?
- Does the rubric focus on the most important skills rather than minor details?
Start by creating or revising a rubric for one assignment, then attach it in Canvas so students can review the expectations before beginning their work.
Rubrics: Designing, Using, and Managing Rubrics in Canvas (QILT Training) (Video) Learn how to build rubrics, attach them to assessments, and use them for grading.
